PDA

View Full Version : Requiem For A Dream

sspencer
16-01-2002, 09:44
Anyone know whether the R2 version of the film is the same as the standard R1 or the Director's Cut. If it is the standard, is there a big difference - both versions seem to be listed at 102 minutes i.e. 98 minutes on PAL.
Edge
16-01-2002, 09:53
All your answers can be found here (http://www.dvdcompare.org.uk/comparisons/film_results_page.php?fid=775) :)

Edge
sspencer
16-01-2002, 10:07
Ooops. I should have expressed myself better - I know the details from the DVDCompare website but it was specifically the film I was interested in not the extras - Huh (sharp intake of breath) heresay!
Bolch
16-01-2002, 11:22
The R2 is exactly the same as the R1 Unrated (aka Director's cut)
Edge
16-01-2002, 11:25
Originally posted by sspencer
Ooops. I should have expressed myself better - I know the details from the DVDCompare website but it was specifically the film I was interested in not the extras - Huh (sharp intake of breath) heresay!

You expressed yourself fine, you just can't read too well as you obviously don't know the details from the DVDCompare website - all the clues are there :)

On that link it states R1 unrated - no cuts; R1 standard - re-edited, see imdb; R2 - no cuts. Therefore it is the same as the unrated R1 version as if it was the same as the standard version it would say re-edited.

Also, if you then check imdb here (http://us.imdb.com/AlternateVersions?0180093) as the site suggests, it tells you the differences between the rated and unrated versions, which I believe covers your original question in its entireity.

Edge
powlest
16-01-2002, 11:52
Which version is my R4 copy then? (I have yet to watch it.)
Richie
16-01-2002, 12:26
On the R2 disc the FILM is the same as the R1 director's cut but on the extras front the R2 MISSES OUT the commentary by cinematographer Matthew Libattique.
James45
22-04-2004, 09:46
how's this for a bump then?

noticed that there are four available versions of this at DVDsoon. The Director's Cut, the Rated, The Unrated and a double pack with Pi.

Does anyone know what version of the film comes in the double pack with Pi?
James45
10-05-2004, 13:17
Does anyone know? Which version do you get with the Requiem/Pi bundle?
Schrader
11-05-2004, 09:24
The Region 4 is uncut.
James45
01-06-2004, 09:13
The Requiem/Pi double pack just arrived (it's just the two seperate releases shrinkwrapped together, no slipcase or anything) and it is indeed the Director's Cut in the package, it's a great deal about £9.20 for both films.