PDA

View Full Version : Good news about R1 Gregory's Girl


Narshty
17-12-2001, 15:45
It has both the original Scottish track, and the milder re-dub (and English subtitles, obviously!).

The transfer is apparently also gorgeous, in it's correct ratio, and anamorphic, making it the one to go for.

DVD Savant explains all (http://www.dvdtalk.com/dvdsavant/s372greg.html)

feverpitch96
17-12-2001, 19:00
WAIT a minute....the film was originally 4:3, or at the very least open matte, wasn't it? I seem to remember Mr Brooke saying this several times...?

The soundtrack news is good, though. :)

Gary Couzens
17-12-2001, 19:38
<i>Gregory's Girl</i> may well have been filmed open-matte, but it's certainly intended for a wider ratio. As it's a low-budget British movie, 1.75:1 is quite likely, and that ratio is close enough to 16:9 to make no difference.

I can't be more specific than that, as it's been quite some time since I saw the film.

Michael Brooke
17-12-2001, 20:28
When I reviewed the R2 disc, I cropped it to 14:9 and it looked absolutely fine - I suspect it would have been shown in 1.66:1 in British cinemas.

But it's rather academic, since - to put it mildly - this isn't one of the world's most overwhelmingly visual films!

Incidentally, I'm delighted to hear about this new release - having seen the dubbed version (or at least the first fifteen minutes, as much as I could stand!), I was worried that that might be the only soundtrack on offer, but if it has the original Scottish <U>and</U> subtitles (something sorely lacking from the R2), it's a clear first choice.

Narshty
17-12-2001, 20:43
It can also be picked up for a smidgen over a tenner.

Nice. ;)