PDA

View Full Version : Has anyone actually listened to all four commentaries on R1 Perfect Storm?

Robby
22-10-2001, 20:42
I keep on putting this off. I want to listen to them but i have this feeling they are going to be dead boring. Am i right??
Just Call Me Wanda
22-10-2001, 20:46
Has anyone actually watched R1 Perfect Storm? :D
dangermouse
22-10-2001, 21:45
Originally posted by robby
I keep on putting this off. I want to listen to them but i have this feeling they are going to be dead boring. Am i right??

I thought Wolfgang Peterson's was great, and the others were also decent.

But to be honest its a pointless question - what one person likes someone else may hate - so listen to them and make your own mind up
APPRIA40WR
22-10-2001, 22:16
The film is complete smeg. 15 mins in and it was turned off.
charlie angel
22-10-2001, 22:42
Bag o' @@@@e film, so there would be approximately no chance of me ever listening to a commentary on it. Unless they were torturing me :D
Robby
22-10-2001, 22:58
I only asked as i'm fed up of watching/listening to boring comms (Me, Myself and Irene anyone?) I thought being as there were four of the buggars someone might be able to recommend one.

I'll try dangermouses suggestion of the Wolfgang one first
charlie angel
22-10-2001, 23:00
Originally posted by robby
I only asked as i'm fed up of watching/listening to boring comms

Too right - you want to hear boring? Check out anything with Robert De Niro doing the commentary (Analyze This, Meet The Rents) Great actor, cannot talk in an interesting manner for lage bits of toffee.
Just Call Me Wanda
22-10-2001, 23:05
Originally posted by charlie angel


Too right - you want to hear boring? Check out anything with Robert De Niro doing the commentary (Analyze This, Meet The Rents) Great actor, cannot talk in an interesting manner for lage bits of toffee.

I agree, however, everytime he talked on the 'Meet The Parents' DVD I found myself sitting up and listening because I just really wanted to know what the guy has to say.
TimK
22-10-2001, 23:23
I really enjoyed the Sebastian Junger commentary, he gives a lot more background information about the actual events. As dangermouse says the Wolfgang one is also very good, haven't listened to the other yet.
Matt.Wild
22-10-2001, 23:49
You mean watch TPS FOUR times, are you sane? :rolleyes: :eek: :D
Rollo Tomassi
23-10-2001, 11:10
Originally posted by TimK
I really enjoyed the Sebastian Junger commentary, he gives a lot more background information about the actual events.

Read the book if you can - it's ace.
Robby
23-10-2001, 11:15
OK thanks guys, i'm a little more psyched about listening to them now. I've also heard bad things about the Meet the Parents Comm, i'll either save that for a very rainy day or wait until i'm very, VERY drunk.

:D